Sidney Crosby snubbed by Sports Illustrated?
In the latest issue of Sports Illustrated (coincidentally enough with the Steelers' Troy Polamalu on it), writer Michael Farber took a stab at what he feels should be the top lines for both the East and West.
I've included the list after the jump, seeing as how I didn't want the stats and such taking up too much space. So if you want to take a look at the list and then give this a read, by all means click "continue reading" below this post.
I don't see how anyone can argue with the picks. Maybe Pens fans would like to make a case for Semin, but aside from that I see an all-star lineup.
Frankly, who can really say this year around that Crosby deserves a nod over Malkin? Geno is scoring more and staying healthy, the latter of which you can hardly hold against Sid. Sid wasn't snubbed, he was outdone.
Let's face it - if there's some sort of list concerning hockey then there's a very good chance Sid will make an appearance. I for one think his absence from this list is justified.
The best thing about all of this is how modest Geno is about all of this. If you've seen some of the videos in the Malkin Learns English collection then you're probably no stranger to Malkin's constant praise of Crosby. Definition: team player.
In the long run there's a good chance that Michael Farber is somewhat of a psychic. After all, it's not like Crosby will be playing much in the All-Star game. That is if in fact the latest release stating Crosby's absence from the ASG holds true. He'll likely show up for the whole face value part of it but whether he plays or not remains a gray area.
As far as I'm concerned, please sit down. We need you where it counts and when it counts, not on the ice in Montreal for a meaningless game.
You can check out the Western picks on SI.com.
In the East, much like in the real All-Star game, select players from only a few teams make the cut. According to Farber, these guys are at the top:
Goalie
Defensemen
Forwards
4 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Seriously, aside from making a case for Crosby, there are at least 5 other players that deserve a nod over Semin. If you factor in injuries, Semin has been injured twice already this year. Why not Kessel, Kovalchuk, or even Lecavalier. As for goalie, Thomas splits time with Frenandez so why not someone who has carried their team on their back all season, like Lundqvist.
Valid point. I think a lot of people, myself included, feel Thomas is owed the nod. I mean, the guy is what – 32? I’m sure Henrik will have plenty more opportunities to shine as the number one pick in similar lists, might as well give it to Thomas now. Can’t deny that he isn’t playing well however, but he definitely has a better defense in front of him than Henrik.
Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com
Kovalchuk??? He is slightly ahead of Semin in points (49 vs. 41) despite playing 18 more games. Kovalchuk is also -8 to a STOUT +23 for Semin. No way Lecavalier deserves the nod this year – maybe in past years. At least you can make an argument for Kessel though I would have probably gone with Savard to feed Geno and Ovi the puck. I think Carter deserves to be in this conversation, too.
In the end, I think the only argument against Semin is that he has been out injured this year. His plus-minus is among the league leaders and Semin and Malkin a blowing away the rest of the league in points per game.
by Moonage Daydream on Jan 24, 2009 11:35 AM EST reply actions
Kovi would’ve been a nice compliment to the line and a definite way to at least work another team into the mix. I don’t see why Semin has to be on the top line.
Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com

by 






















