Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The End Of Sabanball: Details, Barbarians, And Precision

Grades for December and the vote for Player of the Month

 Past months grades and Pensburgh Player of the Month:

October; Alex Goligoski

November; Sidney Crosby

The Penguins registered a 7-5-1 record in December; they rounded back into health and started off playing very well before a little malaise that's seen them lose four of the last five games.  We're all ready to turn over a new leaf in 2010, but let's take a look at the December 09 performances.

Goalies

Grade Comments
Marc-Andre Fleury B (6-4-1, 2.49 GAA,  .912 save percentage on the month) Overall it was a good month for Fleury, even if it didn't end well with losses in 3 of his last 4 games.  He managed to hold opponents to 2 or fewer goals in seven of his eleven games, but he did have four games with a sub-.900 save percentage.
Brent Johnson A (1-1-0, 1.21 GAA .961 save %) He's only going to get 3-5 games a month, but it doesn't mean he can't earn a good grade.  So far Johnson's been everything you could ask for in a backup goalie: uncomplaining about limited playing but ultra-reliable when called upon.
Defensemen         
Mark Eaton B-

(10 games played, 0 goals, 0 assists, +3,  2 penalty minutes)  Playing unnoticeable hockey is a compliment for a defensive defenseman, and Eaton had a relatively quiet month in all facets.

Alex Goligoski C-

(10gp, 0g, 2a, -2, 4 PIMs) Hasn't shown the offensive flair that made him player of the month in October, Goligoski has had a rough month and ended up getting bounced from the top power play unit.

Sergei Gonchar B+ (13gp, 2g, 8a, +3, 6 PIMs)  Gonchar's play on the ice has reverted to it's typical very high levels.  He's averaging 25:01 per night, and no one plays more time on the PK than him either (3:06).  Solid.
Kris Letang C

(13 gp, 0g, 3a, +3, 2 PIMs) Hasn't produced a lot of points, but he did have 23 shots on goal in the month, good enough for second among defenseman (behind Gonch, of course).

Jay McKee B (12gp, 0g, 2a, +1, 6 PIMs)  McKee's blocking shots (1st on team with 93 on the season) and playing steady defense for his teammates.  He's playing his role to the "T".
Brooks Orpik B+

(13gp, 0g, 5a, +8, 12 PIMs) Best plus/minus on the team this month and some heady passes to teammates, the future Olympian is on his game.

Martin Skoula C

(7gp, 0g, 0a, -1, 2 PIMs) Skoula's got to be one of the best insurance policies in the league as a 7th defenseman.  Whenever he's been plugged in, he's been unspectacularly decent.

Forwards                 
Craig Adams C-

(13gp, 0g, 2a, even, 17 PIMs) He fights (not very well), he shoots (not very well) he takes faceoffs (44.0% win rate on the year).  Adams is plugging away, but if his performance isn't improved he might be back to healthy scratch territory.

Matt Cooke C

(12gp, 2g, 2a, even, 10 PIMs)  Some nights he's a difference maker, some nights he doesn't contribute all that much.  Typical 3rd line stuff from a 3rd liner.

Sidney Crosby A-

(12gp, 6g, 9a, +4, 4 PIMs) Got on the scoreboard in 10 of the 11 games that the Penguins registered a goal this month and stayed near the top of the league leaders in goals, points and faceoffs.  Just another month of excellence on a winning hockey team for Sidney Crosby.

Pascal Dupuis B- (13gp, 2g, 3a, +1, 0 PIM) Was hot in November and cooled a little bit; his shots were down 42% from last month to this month (31 to 18) and his goals dropped 60% (from 5 to 2).  Dupuis is in an offensive role as a Top 6 winger, so he needs to play offensively.
Ruslan Fedotenko C-

(12 gp, 3g, 1a, -1, 10 PIMs) Fedotenko's career has shown periods of dry spells and then bursts of a lot of production.  We're still looking for the latter in this season.

Eric Godard D

(8gp, 0g, 1a, +1, 13 PIMs) Only one fight in the month of December (Riley Cote on Dec 15th) and he took four minor penalties.  The least a non-contributing member of the team like Godard can do is not give the other team power plays.

BIll Guerin A-

(13gp, 6g, 5a, +3, 5 PIMs)  Guerin doubled his season's goal total in December, fed some really nice passes and don't forget a fight against a young whippersnapper.  "Dad" is fired up and playing some great hockey.

Tyler Kennedy C-

(12gp, 0g, 1a, -2, 4 PIMs) Kennedy's month started with him losing a shootout and the "honor" of growing a mustache all month.  That was an omen for things to come, rough December for TK that saw him get scratched for the first time.  Now the 'stache is gone, and hopefully the goals will be back.

Chris Kunitz B+ (9gp, 3g, 5a, +1, 6 PIMs) Kunitz returned from injury on Dec 12th and has played at nearly a point per game rate since, a very encouraging month.  4 of his assists were of the PP variety, Kunitz will be an important player in getting it turned around.
Evgeni Malkin B

(13gp, 5g, 8a, +1, 28 PIMs) For a lot of players, this would be a solid month, but Malkin is out of sorts.  He's going to the penalty box a lot -- none of his total are from fights or misconducts, and he just seems a little out of sync.  A very minor problem that he's sure to correct, but he's probably looking to perform a little better.

Mike Rupp B (13gp, 2g, 2a, +4, 31 PIMs) More fights this month than goals (3 to 2) for the Noted one.  He's getting more shifts with Crosby or Malkin, so now is the time for him to show why he deserves the extra ice-time.
Jordan Staal B+

(13gp, 5g, 4a, +6, 4 PIMs) For stretches possibly the best Penguin forward on the ice; Staal had his best goal scoring month of the young season, including a shorty against Philly on Dec 15th.

Maxime Talbot C-

(11gp, 0g, 2a, +1, 14 PIMs)  Is he going to be a 4th line winger?  A guy who gets a chance on the scoring line?  The lack of a role is hurting him, as did being a healthy scratch twice.  His grade is helped since he's not a minus player, but Talbot needs to find a groove and get in it, and hopefully the coaching staff assists him by defining what they're looking for.  His play (and the places he's been used) has shown confusion.

Based off these performances, who's your player of the month?  Like October, this could be seen as a pretty wide-open month.  I'm going to name the following finalists:

  • Sergei Gonchar: for his production of 10 points in 12 games, and his all-around defensive work.
  • Sidney Crosby: for leading the team in goals (tied) assists and points on the month.
  • Bill Guerin: for tying Crosby with 6 goals.
  • Evgeni Malkin: for playing at a point/game rate over the whole month, including his hat-trick performance against Ottawa
  • Jordan Staal: for continuing to be the Pens best PK'ing forward and his goal/point production.

As always, if you think I should have included someone else, please comment on your case.

Poll
Your vote for the Pensburgh Player of the Month:
Sergei Gonchar
9 votes
Sidney Crosby
62 votes
Bill Guerin
55 votes
Evgeni Malkin
3 votes
Jordan Staal
47 votes

176 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 15 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Definitely Guerin. There were a lot of questions about him being too old to skate with Crosby for the first two months of the season, and in December he answered those questions pretty handily.

by SlayerGhaleon on Jan 2, 2010 12:58 PM EST reply actions  

I voted Crosby, I think he was consistently the best player.

I’m a little surprised Staal’s doing so well in early voting. He played well but at one point he was leading the votes!

Pensburgh.com

You come at the king, you best not miss.

by Hooks Orpik on Jan 2, 2010 1:27 PM EST reply actions  

I voted Crosby as well for the very same reason; although, Billy G was a very close second for me. I was really disappointed in Malkin this month. His point production was good, but when the number of points he gets (13) out numbers the number of penalties he takes (14), it’s not a good month.

871

by PensFan8725 on Jan 2, 2010 1:36 PM EST up reply actions  

Shows you how persuasive I am….
Edit: “when the number of penalties he takes (14) out numbers the number of points he gets (13), it’s not a good month.”

871

by PensFan8725 on Jan 2, 2010 1:38 PM EST up reply actions  

Haha, yeah I gotcha. Good dig up on that stat.

Pensburgh.com

You come at the king, you best not miss.

by Hooks Orpik on Jan 2, 2010 1:45 PM EST up reply actions  

For me it was a tie between Crosby, Staal, and Guerin (taking into consideration each player’s role and past performance)… but I voted for Staal because I felt bad for him after he didn’t make Team Canada. And because I keep noticing him in a good way.

by Cari on Jan 2, 2010 2:12 PM EST up reply actions  

Also, his PK work has been good and very important. If other teams had better luck on their power plays, we wouldn’t win as many games.

by Cari on Jan 2, 2010 2:18 PM EST up reply actions  

I think they need to find replacements for Adams and Goddard. I’m thinkin Letestu, maybe Tangradi, Johnson, Conner, or Bayda

by stoopidtom on Jan 2, 2010 1:49 PM EST via mobile reply actions  

Adams = replacement level. Bring anyone up from the minors and it’s the same guy. Can’t knock him too much, though, because he’s as cheap as you can get.

Godard = below replacement level. He needs to be on the next train out of town, thank you.

by JustinM on Jan 2, 2010 1:57 PM EST up reply actions  

Godard needs to be scratched unless it’s Philly.

Tangradi’s still too green to make an impact at the NHL level and Conner made too many mistakes.

I wouldn’t mind seeing someone like Letestu, Johnson or Caputi getting another chance, but none of those guys have much NHL experience. The Pens need reliable players. Adams may not be great, but he doesn’t make too many mistakes. Rookies, however, are much more an unknown quantity, especially for a team that aspires to win night in and night out.

Pensburgh.com

You come at the king, you best not miss.

by Hooks Orpik on Jan 2, 2010 2:17 PM EST up reply actions  

In the one game I saw Letestu I think he put on a pretty good show. I don’t remember who they were playing against, but he did have a pretty sweet set up to Crosby on some bizarre whirling, twirling centering pass. Also wasn’t too heavy on his feet and played the corners well. Kinda reminded me of TK when he got called up in 07.

Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.

by FrankD on Jan 2, 2010 5:48 PM EST up reply actions  

Adams really has been below his not great, but steady standard this month… and I’d love to see any of the Jeffrey-Letestu-Johnson line get promoted to play a few NHL games. Caputi’s form has dropped a bit in the last 6 or 7 games down in WBS.

Godard must sit out most games… we have Rupp to replace him in fights.

You have to see it for yourself...

by Bla Razor on Jan 3, 2010 11:02 AM EST up reply actions  

And btw, I tallied a vote for Sid. If I could spread two votes out (which kinda sorta defeats the purpose of the vote) I’d also give on to Guerin.

Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.

by FrankD on Jan 2, 2010 5:51 PM EST reply actions  

Billy G

I voted Guerin first to acknowledge his contribution and second to redeem myself for calling him “too old already” earlier in the season:)

You have to see it for yourself...

by Bla Razor on Jan 3, 2010 11:04 AM EST reply actions  

Sorry but the grade for Malkin is way too high. Yea he is still putting up a decent point total. However his play has been terrible, he has become a liability on the ice. Absolutely terrible turnovers on a consistent basis lately. Not to the fault of his own but, having him on the left point on the powerplay is well, pointless. Hes not shooting from there, he cant shoot a one-timer the penguins only real “play” on the PP, and hes a liability for SH goals now. Gogo or Gonch aren’t able to pinch as much if they have to worry about where Geno is. Granted Geno hasn’t gotten any help from his line mates, Dupuis and Feds have been terrible too. I dont quite understand playing both of them on their off wing a lot of times either. The past 2 years the Pens have traded to find a wing for Crosby, its time they show Geno some love and get him someone to play with.

by genomachine-O on Jan 4, 2010 12:29 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Pensburgh.com - a Pittsburgh Penguins blog dedicated to building a community of, by and for Pittsburgh Penguins fans

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Mario_saves_small
Game Photos: 2/12/2012 Pens vs Lightning
Mario_saves_small
Game Photos: 2012-02-11 Pens vs Jets
Small
Who signs, gets traded, or walks?
Image1326398056_small
Ovechkin Still Doesn't Get It
Small
Comparing injuries and games played in the NHL
Mario_saves_small
Game Photos: 1/22/2012 Pens vs Caps
Me_small
Should Crosby Give Up His C?
Mario_saves_small
Game Photos: 1/20/2012 Pens vs Canadiens
Sheroevillaugh_small
An Addendum to "Will it ever end?"
Rothko_1964
My 20 years of being a Penguins fan

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Penguins_cup_08__small FrankD

Me2_small Hooks Orpik

Me_small Stephen Catanese

Editors

Mepiano_small JustinM

Authors

Dan_aeconley_small Lavender

Pens_ring_small GoPens!

Me___small TonyAndrock

Rome_small LauraZ

Moderators

Photo_small tehchico