The Penguins' 1st Round Pick
The Pittsburgh Penguins will have the 20th overall pick in the first round of this year's NHL entry draft. While the draft might be overshadowed by the recently completed Stanley Cup playoffs, those who ignore the significance of the selections do so at their own peril. Successful drafting is critical to replenishing an organization's depth and remaining competitive in today's salary cap league. Considering that the Penguins' 1st round pick has a decent chance to become an impact player at the NHL level, who they select will have important ramifications in the future.
I'll be limiting my review to those who play a position the Penguins are likely to draft in the first round and who would likely be available around the 20th pick. The Pens have a ton of quality centermen and goalies within the organization, and I'd be shocked if they used their 1st round pick this year to select a player at that position. Likewise, the Penguins are relatively young at defensemen, and they selected Simon Depres last year in the 1st round. This leaves us with players who play wing. I think the Pens are likely to draft a winger in the 1st round due to the lack of quality wings at the NHL level, and the discrepancy in talent between Eric Tangradi and the next closest winger in the AHL.
Let's find out who's out there.
John McFarland, Sudbury Wolves (OHL), LWThe Skinny: McFarland is known for being one of the fastest players in the OHL and having a really good wrist shot, as both his coach and E.J. McGuire have confirmed. He's also recently worked on his defensive game to become a better two-way forward. His coach says that he has really started to contribute in the defensive zone by initiating contact and not shying away from players with the puck. His 50 points this past year was second on his team, and he previously captained Canada's U-18 team to a gold medal at the 2009 Memorial of Ivan Hlinka Tournament.
Youtube: Check out this fight and player profile.
Stanislav Galiev, Saint John Sea Dogs (OMJHL), RW
The Skinny: Galiev is a dynamic player who can be very creative with the puck. He's also an intelligent player who backchecks hard and plays at both ends of the ice. While he's inconsistent when it comes to capitalizing on his chances right now, most scouts are happy to see that he's committed to playing in the NHL, and that he has the talent to become an impact player for quite some time. His draft stock has been rising over the course of the season, and some projections have him as high as the 15th overall pick.
Youtube: Check out this goal and player profile.
Petr Straka, Rimouski Oceanic (OMJHL), RW
The Skinny: Straka is a speedy winger with great hands and a nose for the net. He was an important member of Rimouski's deadly power play unit, and won the QMJHL's Rookie of the Year award after leading all rookies in goals and points. E.J. McGuire sees high-end potential in Straka, who reminds him of Martin Erat or Pavel Dmitra. For those who are looking for still more information on Petr, check out this phenomenal write-up the guys over at In Lou We Trust put together.
Youtube: Check out this shootout goal and player profile.
Kirill Kabanov, Moncton Wildcats (QMJHL), LW
The Skinny: "He's highly talented -- as talented as any player in the draft." Those are the words of E.J. McGuire when discussing the potential of Kirill Kabanov. But he is not without his downside. A wrist injury this year sidelined him for most of the season, and we're not sure how that's going to affect the rest of his game. He was also dropped by his agent and dismissed from the U-18 Russian team. The consensus seems to be that Kabanov has the ability and on-ice tools to be a very good NHL player. But whether he has the mentality to handle the off-ice stuff that comes with being a professional athlete is still a lingering question.
Youtube: Check out his draft profile.
That's all I've got for potential 1st round picks. It should go without saying that there are plenty of other talented players that I didn't cover who could very easily be drafted and become successful NHL stars; I only tried to highlight the most likely possibilities for the Penguins this year. Yet regardless of who they choose, here's to hoping it's a future Hall-of-Famer.
37 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
From what I’ve read Kabanov sounds like a headcase. I don’t doubt his skill but I’m not sure I would want him on the team. I would draft Petr Straka simply for his name, but Shero has said before that when it comes to our turn in the draft he’s going to take the best available player, not necessarily the best available winger.
by Mario's Mullet on Jun 19, 2010 10:28 AM EDT via mobile reply actions
he’s going to take the best available player, not necessarily the best available winger.
Do you have a link?
I really hope the Pens draft a winger. Even if by some measurement Shero thinks a particular centerman or Dman is better than the remaining wingers, the difference in talent has to be close to negligible.
Author at Pensburgh.com
Third-to-last paragraph in this one.
Basically saying that eventhough the current depth chart has Crosby, Malkin and Staal at center, and MAF in net, the Pens shouldn’t pass up a playmaking center or future number one goalie in the draft. Those are the team’s strong areas now, but you can’t predict how your team will look three years from now when current draft picks are knocking on the door. In my opinion, it’s a smart move because it assures us that we’re getting the proper value for our picks. Granted if a good winger is ranked a couple spots lower when it comes Shero’s turn to draft, he might be more persuaded to take the winger.
by Mario's Mullet on Jun 19, 2010 2:14 PM EDT up reply actions
Granted if a good winger is ranked a couple spots lower when it comes Shero’s turn to draft, he might be more persuaded to take the winger.
That’s what I had in mind with my above comment.
Author at Pensburgh.com
http://penguins.nhl.com/club/news.htm?id=532054&navid=DL|PIT|home
http://penguins.nhl.com/club/news.htm?id=532019&navid=DL|PIT|home
^Third-to-last paragraph in this one. Can’t get the links to work.
by Mario's Mullet on Jun 19, 2010 2:15 PM EDT up reply actions
I just checked, and Petr isn’t related to Marty. That’s what I thought too.
by stoopidtom on Jun 19, 2010 1:37 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
I think it’s the best approach to the Draft in general. It definitely applies to the first round, but I think more so with the later picks. Save for the last round and whatnot.
Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.
Save for the last round and whatnot.
Can you explain what you mean by that last comment? (Thx!)
Go, Shero, Go!!! And also Brian Burke.
Maybe a typo—“safe” not “save”
Cидни Kросби: Александр Oвечкин, он твой папа теперь
матовая Клими, Михал нуивирт ваш папа теперь
Red Line Station: for Capitals fans who can bear reading something less intelligent than a story at Japers' Rink
Follow me on Twitter!
by red army line on Jun 19, 2010 3:53 PM EDT up reply actions
It could also mean that the latter rounds may see more latitude in terms of moving away from the best player available, since by 4th and 5th rounds, the players all tend to have some areas they need to work on and are roughly equivalent. So, the team may look more to what it needs overall, rather than the best available. There is a good article on the Pens site from Jason Spiedling talking about the draft. It is well worth the read to see what the Pens strategy is.
Sounds like “save for” in this case means “with the exception of”.
The Pens will be back.
by PensAreYourDaddy on Jun 19, 2010 8:35 PM EDT up reply actions
Save for, as PensAreYourDaddy and SuMac described below. Once you get into the deeper rounds teams don’t really pick the best player available because, frankly, there isn’t much there to distinguish one from the other. This is normally the point where you start seeing guys taken based on last name if they’re related to a former NHLer on the team with the pick or, like the Pens did last year, they dished the last pick to Montreal to close out the Montreal Draft WITH a Montreal pick.
Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.
Ha! I totally didn’t pay attention and thought that first reply was from you. It seemed odd to me that you didn’t really know what was confusing about it. Anyway, your explanation helps. I don’t really have an opinion on the matter, but I find it’s generally helpful to actually understand other people’s thoughts and opinions when I’m thinking about this stuff. Makes me more smarterer and stuff.
Go, Shero, Go!!! And also Brian Burke.
It’s all good. That’s why we have this whole chat thing available to us.
Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.
Obviously I wouldn’t want to see us draft a winger who’s 20 ranks lower than the next player simply because he’s a winger. But I think that drafting a centerman or Dman in the first round does not address our team’s most critical needs. We seem to have an increasingly tough time getting quality wingers at the deadline in March or through free agency in July. It would make sense to draft some wingers in the first round to ease the lack of depth at that position.
And considering that players around the 14-25 spot all have about the same chance of becoming impact players in the NHL, there isn’t much of a reason to draft a player who isn’t a right or left wing.
Author at Pensburgh.com
I don’t know much about the players in the draft, but i think i would rather have one of the defensemen from the USDP. I have seen mock drafts where Merrill, Tinordi, & Johns all fall to the Pens at 20. From what Ive read they all seem like big physical puck moving defensmen that can also skate. Sounds like someone where looking for now. Too bad nobody could step in and help us right away
by StripesForLife on Jun 19, 2010 10:43 AM EDT reply actions
Dylan McIlrath
McIlrath is big, fast, mean and has a strong shot. Pair him with Despres as a shut down pairing for the future. Folks, Our need is for defensemen not wingers. Offense was fine last season.
Our need for defensemen in the present is much greater than in the future. And since drafted players at our slot won’t have an impact in present time, I think the consideration of who to draft should revolve around future implications.
With Goligoski, Orpik, Letang, Lovejoy, and Despres, we have plenty of talented young defensemen who are only getting better with time. At the wing position, we have Tangradi in the minors and no 25-30 goal scorer in the NHL. Having Crosby and Malkin on our team should make us take the idea of getting quality wingers even more seriously.
Author at Pensburgh.com
Dylan McIlrath
Everyone, including you, believe that it the Pens’ blue line that is “soft” or as MT put it “soff” , all of you who want the puck in the defensive end for shifts at a time long for Gill and Scuderi who couldn’t make an exit pass between them. If you really want grit and toughness, bring back Joey Mormina and play him with Lovejoy. They were the best shut down pair in the AHL in 08-09. Look at their +/-. Draft McIlrath and play him with Despres to compete with Goligoski and Leopold/Eaton, trade Leopold or Eaton or Goligoski if they do not prevail . They will be another tough pairing against whom to skate. Letang and Orpik are already superior defensive defensemen. Engelland would make the perfect tough 7th defensemen. All but Orpic and Letang can be had for cheap.
Quiz— “The flag of morn in conqueror’s state
Enters at the English gate,
The vanquished eve as night prevails,
Bleeds upon the road to Wales.”
Where does this take place and when?
I like the idea of McIlrath and Despres as the shutdown defensive pairing of the future. From what I’ve seen of McIlrath, he’s a huge body that’s very sound definsively. Offense isn’t his thing, so we shouldn’t expect much point production out of him.
by Mario's Mullet on Jun 20, 2010 9:45 AM EDT up reply actions
I like Mcllrath too, from what I have read. We don’t need anymore offensive defensemen!!
A big body, sound and solid in front of the net would help us. The key, is the defensive pairing of the future, as you wrote.
—I just read Rossi’s column and he stated that Shero is in talk with Gonchar, more agressively now…do you really think Gonchar will take the “hometown” discount? I don’t want to sound mean, but I don’t think he is that unselfish. Just my opinion.
One Who Lives And Breathes All Things Penguins
by PensFanInDenver on Jun 20, 2010 10:12 AM EDT up reply actions
It's a tough call
I really like Gonchar and what he brings to the team, but too many times he just seems like a defensive liability. If I’m Gonchar, I wouldn’t care about the extra couple million dollars I could make on the open market. I’d want to stay with a team that I’m confortable and recently won a Cup with. Not to mention getting to play in the new arena and Winter Classic. It’s one of those things where if we lose him I’m not too upset, and if we re-sign him I’m still happy.
by Mario's Mullet on Jun 20, 2010 1:25 PM EDT up reply actions
Two two-way gritty/fighter forward who can score is all the craze. Alex Burrows is doing it in Vancouver, Matt Cooke did it with the Pens and frankly I like what I’ve read and see on McFarland.
Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.
wingers?
Defense defense defense. The Pens MUST select a defensmen in the first round to help round out their stable of blueliners. Wingers can be had for the cheap, and as mentioned above the Pens ranked 5th in goals for last year. Goal scoring is not an issue with this team.
On a side note, Philly just traded for Hamhuis. so, yeah, DEFENSE
How exciting for these young guys. I remember waiting FOREVER for the Pens to pick last year. Then I reminded myself that fans of teams like the Oilers and Isles would die to pick 30th.
I’m interested to see the Pens pick this year (kind of an obvious comment). I want to say they’ll pick a winger, but I wouldn’t be surprised to see a D man go.
I've told [a 9 months pregnant] Nathalie that she can't have the baby on a game night. I'm not missing a playoff game. -Mario Lemieux in 1993
I’m getting very excited too. This will be my first NHL draft where I actually follow the picks pretty seriously.
Author at Pensburgh.com
same here.
(okay, this is off topic, but i’m curious: i’ve heard a rumor- dustin jeffrey for sopel and ladd. thoughts?)
STAAL FOR SELKE. SIDNEY FOR EVERY OTHER ONE OR JUST THE HART AND THE MESSIER LEADERSHIP AWARD. THAT IS ACCEPTABLE.
by katielynn906 on Jun 19, 2010 8:07 PM EDT up reply actions
Ladd yes, Sopel not so sure, yes he looked quite good in the finals but I’ve heard quite some less flattering things of him from earlier.
There is a knack to flying: it's learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss.
by Sid the captain on Jun 19, 2010 8:21 PM EDT up reply actions
I would re-negotiate that deal to throw in another player so we could get Ladd and Hjalmarsson.
Author at Pensburgh.com
Ladd and Hjalmarsson are RFAs, so a trade would be for the right to make qualifying offers and then attempt to sign them before 7/1, at which point the offer sheet, salary arbitration, right to match or receive draft choice compensation rules kick in. Maybe to much risk with that.
I’d take Ladd at a reasonable salary ($2.5M or so) as a LW for Geno over any of the available UFAS,
I would say go with a Winger first, D second. Can’t wait to see what happens Friday!
Either way, it’s a toss up. But a big, stay-at-home D, not another puck moving one.
One Who Lives And Breathes All Things Penguins
by PensFanInDenver on Jun 20, 2010 9:42 AM EDT reply actions
Tyler Toffoli from the Ottawa 67’s is the way to go. Great, speedy winger with a deadly shot. He’s also North American, which makes him Shero’s kind of player.
Kabanov would be a home run pick, but he has the “Russian factor,” meaning he’s no safe bet to play in the NHL.
He’s also North American, which makes him Shero’s kind of player.
Curious. I haven’t heard this specifically about Shero before. Is this a common perception of Shero?
Go, Shero, Go!!! And also Brian Burke.
Not sure if you can make a case for a Shero North American bias, but he seems to prefer big players based on his drafts. I’d like to see him take a chance on a smaller high-skill guy. Toffoli would fit that description — although I’ve read his skating isn’t NHL-caliber now, but his shot is said to be one of the best in the draft.
I’ll also throw out the name of Jeffrey Skinner, a 5’10" 180ish forward from Kitchener. He led the OHL in goals — yes, more than Taylor Hall, although Hall did miss about 10 games due to the WJC — and scouts are on record saying he may be end up being a steal if he goes in the late 1st round as projected.






















